More Coverage
Twitter Coverage
JOIN SATYAAGRAH SOCIAL MEDIA
Supreme Court allows one-time Karthigai Deepam lighting at Madurai's Thirupparankundram hill on November 24 while staying the Madras High Court order amid the century-old Deepathoon clash and CM Vijay's stance

On Friday, November 20, 2026, the Supreme Court of India cleared the way for the ceremonial lighting of the ‘Karthigai Deepam’ atop Thirupparankundram hill in Madurai, Tamil Nadu, for the upcoming Karthigai Deepam festival taking place on November 24, 2026. The order was delivered by a two-judge Bench consisting of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi.
|
While granting this permission, the judges attached a clear condition: only officially authorized representatives from the Devasthanam—the temple's governing administration—alongside designated government officials will be permitted to carry out the lamp-lighting ritual.
In arriving at this interim decision, the Bench weighed the immediate realities surrounding the festival date. The judges pointed out that if the lighting of the sacred lamp were blocked on the actual day of the celebration, no legal relief granted at a later point could ever undo that loss or make up for the missed occasion. At the same time, the court made it unmistakably clear that this approval is strictly a one-time arrangement meant solely for this year's festival. The Bench went further to caution all parties involved that allowing the ceremony this year does not establish any legal right concerning religious custom, public access, or property ownership over the hill. “At this stage, it is neither necessary nor appropriate to express any opinion on the competing claims,” the bench said.
To make sure the event unfolds smoothly and without incident, the Supreme Court instructed the Madurai District Collector to determine the exact size and makeup of the team that will ascend the hill to light the lamp. The Collector must finalize these details after holding consultations with the Executive Officer of the temple, representatives of the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI), and the Commissioner of Police. Under the court's directions, the District Collector will personally oversee all arrangements on the ground. Meanwhile, local police forces will be responsible for maintaining security, with the option to bring in support from the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) if the situation demands it. To prevent any overcrowding or unrest, the court strictly banned all public gatherings, processions, and demonstrations on the hill while the lamp-lighting ceremony is underway.
Even as it cleared the path for the ritual to take place on November 24, the Supreme Court placed a stay on an earlier decision delivered in January by a Division Bench of the Madras High Court, which had permitted the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam on a stone pillar situated on the lower peak of the hill. The apex court underlined that its temporary permission for this year's festival must not be “construed as an endorsement of the reasoning adopted by the High Court or as a final determination of the competing claims over the disputed site”.
|
Understanding the Dispute
The legal battle before the courts centers on a long-standing disagreement over Thirupparankundram hill in Madurai, Tamil Nadu. What makes this hill particularly sensitive is that it is home to sacred sites belonging to three different religious communities: Hindus, Jains, and Muslims. At the base of the hill stands the revered Arulmigu Subramaniya Swamy Temple, which is recognized as one of the six sacred abodes of Lord Murugan. At the very top of the hill sits the Sikandar Badusha Avuliya Dargah, a shrine dedicated to the Sufi saint Sikandar Badusha. Alongside these two active places of worship, the hill also preserves ancient Jain caves, stone inscriptions, and carved rock beds.
For generations, the hill has held deep significance in Hindu religious traditions. However, the latest round of conflict broke out last year when Hindu devotees sought to light the traditional ceremonial lamp—the Karthigai Deepam—at the top of the hill. Their effort met with strong opposition from members of the Muslim community as well as the Tamil Nadu state government. Both objected to lighting the lamp on the hilltop stone pillar, pointing to how close the pillar stands to the Sikandar Badusha Dargah.
When the dispute reached the Madras High Court in December 2025, a single-judge Bench presided over by Justice G. R. Swaminathan ruled in favor of the Hindu devotees' petition. Justice Swaminathan directed the administration of the Arulmigu Subramania Swamy Temple to go ahead and light the lamp at the stone pillar, which is known as the Deepathoon. That December directive was later challenged, and in January 2026, a Division Bench of the Madras High Court upheld the single judge's ruling. The Supreme Court's current interim order has been issued while hearing the appeals filed by the Tamil Nadu government against that January decision of the High Court's Division Bench.
|
Extra Special MEMU Trains Announced for Karthigai Deepam
With large numbers of pilgrims expected to travel for the Karthigai Deepam festival, the Tiruchy division of Southern Railway has announced that it will run additional unreserved MEMU train services from several starting points to Tiruvannamalai on November 23, 24, and 25. These extra trains are intended to ease travel and help devotees reach the festival town comfortably.
Among the key services, a special 12-coach MEMU train will operate between Chennai Beach and Tiruvannamalai across all three days. This train will depart from Chennai Beach at 6:20 am and arrive in Tiruvannamalai at 11:40 am. For the return trip, the service will leave Tiruvannamalai at 11:55 pm and pull into Chennai at 4:35 am the next morning. Along its route, this 12-coach train will make scheduled stops at Perambur, Villivakkam, Ambattur, Tiruninravur, Tiruvallur, Arakkonam, Sholinghur, Walajah Road, Katpadi, and Vellore Cantonment.
In addition to the Chennai service, Southern Railway will operate four other 12-coach MEMU trains between Katpadi and Tiruvannamalai, with two services running in each direction. Passengers boarding these trains will have stops at Polur, Arni Road, and Vellore Cantonment.
Another special train service has been scheduled between Tambaram and Tiruvannamalai. It will leave Tambaram at 9:15 am and reach Tiruvannamalai by 1:30 pm. On its way back, the return train will depart Tiruvannamalai at 10:25 pm and arrive in Tambaram at 2:30 am. Beyond these routes, railway authorities will also run special services connecting Villupuram and Tiruvannamalai, as well as between Vellore Cantonment and Villupuram, with scheduled halts at Tiruvannamalai and several other intermediate stations.
|
Karthigai Deepam Dispute: A Look at Tamil Nadu’s Century-Old Hill Row
By granting a one-time approval to light the ceremonial lamp on November 24, the Supreme Court has stepped into a property and worship disagreement in Tamil Nadu's Madurai district that has been contested for more than a century between a Hindu temple and a neighboring Muslim dargah. In its interim order on Friday, November 20, the apex court made it clear that only people authorized by the Subramanian Swamy temple and government officials may carry out the ceremony at the disputed stone pillar on Thirupparankundram hill—the same hill that houses the Sulthan Sikkandar Avulia Dargah. This latest ruling adds another chapter to a hundred-year-old dispute over the site, tracing back to how the conflict first began, how it shaped decades of religious practice on the hill, and how it flared up once again in December last year.
|
Origins of the Thirupparankundram Legal Battle
Standing on the outskirts of Madurai, Thiruparankundram hill rises to a height of roughly 1,050 feet. At its foothills sits the Arulmigu Subramanian Swamy Cave Temple, a center of Hindu worship for centuries. Over the long span of its history, the hill also became a site for Jain rock beds and caves that were carved out across many centuries. At the very summit lies the burial site of the Sufi saint Sikkandar Badhusha, where a dargah was later established.
Because of these overlapping religious histories, the hill has come to hold more than a single identity. Over time, it has been called “Samanar Hill” owing to its Jain heritage, and “Sikkandar Hill” in reference to the Sufi saint buried at its peak. It has also become a place where police personnel are routinely deployed during major festivals, as questions regarding public access and movement tend to arise during those periods.
The formal legal history of the hill dates all the way back to a civil lawsuit filed in 1920. In that case, the Arulmigu Subramanian Swamy Temple Devasthanam, which manages the temple's affairs, staked a claim of ownership over the entire hill. Three years later, in 1923, the trial court issued a ruling that divided the property: it declared that most of the unoccupied hill and the pilgrim pathway belonged to the temple, while the topmost peak, the area immediately surrounding the mosque, the Nellithope area, and the steps leading up to the mosque were recognized as Muslim property. That 1923 division laid the legal foundation for many of the disputes that followed in later years.
|
Past Flashpoints
Legal disagreements over Thiruparankundram continued to surface across the decades. In 2021, a dispute broke out over a move to replace a wooden flagstaff at the dargah with an iron one. More recently, in early 2025, another controversy emerged following an attempt to carry out animal sacrifice at the hilltop. A three-judge Bench later stepped in to prohibit the practice, pointing out that the hill is a protected monument governed by the rules of the Archaeological Survey of India.
The current dispute focuses specifically on lighting a festival lamp at a stone pillar located near the hilltop, approximately 50 metres away from the dargah. Devotees describe this pillar as a Deepathoon, a traditional ceremonial structure built for lighting lamps. However, historical records submitted before the court revealed that authorities had stopped attempts to light lamps near the summit back in the 19th and early 20th centuries, citing both the lack of an established custom and concerns over maintaining public order.
The question returned to the courts in 1994 when volunteers sought permission to light a Deepam at the peak. In a 1996 judgment, the High Court directed that the Karthigai Deepam should instead be lit at a different spot on the lower slopes, near the Uchipillaiyar Temple. At the same time, the court left room for the Devasthanam to consider alternative sites, provided that the “suitable place [is] at least 15 metres away from the Dargah, the flight of steps and the Nellithope area”. Following that ruling, the Deepam was lit for decades at the Deepa Mandapam near the Uchipillaiyar temple.
|
How the Thirupparankundram Row Flares Up Again
It was against this historical backdrop that a group of worshippers approached the court in late November 2025, asking for permission to light the Karthigai Deepam at the hilltop “Deepathoon” on December 3. On December 1, a single-judge bench granted their petitions. Viewing the ritual as the restoration of a religious practice, the judge directed the temple management to light the lamp with police support.
“Karthigai is also a festival of light. Lamps are lit all over the house and not in the pooja room alone. The Karthigai Deepam shall be lit from this year onwards at Deepathoon also,” the court said. When temple officials voiced hesitation about carrying out the directive due to law-and-order concerns, the judge initiated contempt proceedings and permitted a small team to climb the hill under security protection.
|
Objections Raised by the State
The state government, together with the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department, challenged the single judge's directive. They argued that disagreements over religious customs and traditional usage must be settled under the provisions of the HR&CE Act rather than through writ proceedings in court. State officials also questioned whether the stone pillar was even a religious structure, suggesting instead that it might be a survey marker or a remnant tied to Jain use.
Pointing to concerns over crowd control and maintaining public peace, the police enforced prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. As a consequence, the lamp was not lit on the festival day last year, which in turn led to formal appeals filed by the State, the HR&CE Department, and representatives of the dargah.
|
What the High Court Division Bench Decided
Earlier this year, a Division Bench of the Madras High Court heard those appeals and delivered its ruling. The Bench concluded that the stone structure was indeed a Deepathoon, pointing out that it featured a carved cavity capable of holding oil and wicks, and firmly rejected the argument that it was merely a survey marker.
Addressing the administration's warnings about potential unrest, the court remarked that those fears were “nothing but an imaginary ghost,” noting that allowing a small group of temple officials to climb the hill once a year could not reasonably be viewed as unmanageable. Even so, the Division Bench modified the single judge's earlier order. It directed that the Devasthanam could light the lamp at the Deepathoon only through a limited team, with no public access permitted. The District Collector was tasked with coordinating the ritual, subject to conditions laid down by the Archaeological Survey of India to safeguard the monument.
|
How the Dispute Reached the Apex Court
In June this year, the Tamil Nadu government moved the Supreme Court to challenge the Division Bench's judgment, and the dargah authorities along with other parties also approached the top court. On Wednesday, the Tamil Nadu government argued that allowing the lamp to be lit at the stone pillar near the dargah could set a precedent where thousands of survey pillars across the country end up acquiring a religious character.
Taking up the matter ahead of this year's Karthigai Deepam festival, the Supreme Court on November 20 issued its interim order permitting the lamp to be lit at the disputed pillar on November 24, strictly as a one-time measure with safeguards in place, while staying the Madras High Court judgment that had allowed the lighting of the lamp at the “Deepathoon”.
Prior to that Friday order, the Supreme Court had heard the Thiruparankundram Karthigai Deepam case for a third consecutive day on November 19, focusing on arguments over the traditional lighting of the temple lamp atop the stone pillar (Deepathoon) in Madurai district. At the close of that day's session, the apex court scheduled the hearing to resume on November 20, with counsel for the main petitioner, Rama Ravikumar, set to continue his submissions regarding interim relief ahead of the November 24 festival. Throughout these hearings, the Supreme Court was examining the Tamil Nadu government's plea for a stay on the Madras High Court's direction. On November 18, the State government had urged the court to maintain the status quo, repeating its warning that enforcing the High Court's order could impart a religious identity to thousands of survey pillars nationwide.
The Division Bench of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi heard the appeals contesting the Madras High Court's January 6, 2026, Division Bench verdict, which had upheld Justice G. R. Swaminathan's December 2025 order permitting the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam atop the stone pillar near the Sikandar Badusha Dargah on Thiruparankundram hill.
|
Petitioner Contends Physical Features Prove Pillar Is a Deepathoon
During the November 19 hearing, senior counsel Valliappan, representing the main petitioner Rama Ravikumar, argued that the bowl-shaped cavity or cup carved into the top of the stone pillar serves as clear physical proof that the structure is an ancient Deepathoon designed to hold oil or ghee along with a cotton wick.
He maintained that the structure is a traditional lamp pillar rather than a British-era survey stone, as the Tamil Nadu government has claimed. Drawing attention to similar stone pillars located at Swamimalai, Maruthamalai near Coimbatore, Palani, and other hill abodes of Bhagwan Murugan, Valliappan argued that the State government's stance was mistaken. He also pushed back against the Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) government's claim that the pillar was either a survey marker or a lamp post belonging to a Jain congregation. Valliappan delivered his arguments for roughly 15 minutes on November 19 before time constraints forced the remainder of his submissions to be carried over to the morning of November 20.
Dargah Committee Challenges Justice Swaminathan’s Site Visit
Also on November 19, the Sikandar Badusha Dargah Committee raised objections to the way Madras High Court Justice G. R. Swaminathan had conducted a site inspection of the disputed Deepathoon on Thiruparankundram hill before issuing his order allowing the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam. Senior advocate Huzefa Ahmadi, representing the Dargah Committee, told the court that the inspection was carried out without giving prior notice to the Committee and without affording it a fair opportunity to present its side.
“In my respectful submission ordinarily a writ court, a constitutional court, does not conduct private inspection. These findings would not have been returned if we were given notice, if we were able to assist the learned judge at the site,” he submitted. Ahmadi also questioned a shift in how the disputed property was described, pointing out that the wording ‘whole of the hillock’ had been altered to ‘just Dargah’, even though the original decree used the phrase ‘the whole of the hillock’. The Dargah Committee had previously maintained that the single judge carried out the site visit without informing them and before giving them adequate time to file a reply.
Tamil Nadu Government Points to Communal Harmony
Seeking a stay on the High Court's directive, the C. Joseph Vijay-led TVK government argued that allowing the Deepam to be lit near the Dargah could disturb communal harmony and spark communal tensions. During the November 18 proceedings, the State government contended that shifting the lamp-lighting from the Uchippillaiyar temple tower atop the hill to the disputed Deepathoon could lead to thousands of survey pillars across India being given a religious character, while again emphasizing how close the pillar stands to the Dargah.
Counsel representing the Madurai District Collector likewise maintained that the disputed structure was a British-era survey pillar and not a Deepathoon. The Dargah Committee also reiterated its challenge to the single judge's site inspection. After hearing submissions from the Tamil Nadu government, the Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments (HR&CE) Department, the Madurai District Collector, and the Dargah Committee on November 17 and 18, the Supreme Court moved on to the Hindu petitioner's arguments for interim relief on November 19.
Political Row Over the State Government’s Position
The TVK government's arguments before the Supreme Court quickly triggered political pushback. The Tamil Nadu BJP criticized the administration's stand, accusing it of putting minority votes ahead of Hindu religious sentiments. In a post on X, BJP Tamil Nadu charged that the TVK government, eager to hold onto minority votes, had hurt Hindu sentiments by arguing in court that the disputed structure was a survey post rather than a Deepathoon.
We the Leaders founder K. Annamalai also took aim at the conflicting positions adopted by successive Tamil Nadu governments regarding the exact same structure. He recalled that in December 2025, the HR&CE Department under the previous DMK government had informed the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court that the Deepathoon atop Thiruparankundram hill had been placed there by Jain monks to light lamps—a stance that contradicted its own earlier claim that the pillar was a survey stone. Annamalai pointed out that the current TVK government, speaking through the Madurai District Collector, had now gone back to calling the structure a survey stone before the Supreme Court.
“How can a govt have entirely contradictory positions on the very same structure before two courts? This only reflects a serious lapse in the TN govt’s (Be it DMK then or TVK now) understanding or a deliberate misunderstanding of the subject as a whole,” Annamalai said. Another social media post claimed that the DMK government had originally been the first to label the structure a survey stone instead of a Deepam pillar, only to shift its stance when faced with evidence. In those earlier proceedings, the State had relied on historical references presented by HR&CE counsel N. Jothi, who argued that the pillar was built by Jain sages and compared it to Jain pillars at Samanar Hills and Shravanabelagola. Meanwhile, a plaque at the Dargah reportedly records its construction in 1805, raising questions about earlier claims linking it to the 10th and 12th centuries. Thiruparankundram is recognized as the first among the six sacred abodes of Bhagwan Murugan.
Online Reactions and Scrutiny of Official Statements
The courtroom arguments also sparked widespread reactions on social media, with activists questioning the statements attributed to officials. Social media activist Sanghi Prince criticized the Madurai District Collector's reported submissions regarding both the pillar's identity and the history of the land. In a post on X, he quoted the courtroom exchange as follows:
“Collector: Thiruparankundram pillar is not the Deepam pillar. Such pillars exist even on Mount Everest. Judge: Does the area where the pillar stands belong to Hindus or not? Collector: I don’t know, saar.”
Commenting on the exchange, he asked how government officials could claim to know the history of the pillar while admitting they did not know the history of the land it stands on, and called for scrutiny of officials who, in his view, approached the court with one-sided and unverified claims.
Elsewhere, temple activist Rangarajan Narasimhan noted that his own case concerning the missing Mylapore peacock murti could not be taken up due to time constraints. Speaking about the Deepam proceedings, he mentioned that Rama Ravikumar's counsel Valliappan had wrapped up roughly 15 minutes of arguments on November 19 and would continue on the morning of November 20, adding that he had offered to provide whatever help was needed in the Deepam case.
Another social media activist directly questioned Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay's handling of the issue, urging him to simply enforce the court's directive rather than view the matter through the lens of political calculations and vote-bank considerations. “But if you (CM Joseph Vijay) disappoint us over the Thiruparankundram Deepam issue, I won’t stay silent. Your job is very simple, Vijay sir. There is a court order. You have to Just implement it,” the post stated.
A Hindu devotee also voiced strong disagreement with the argument that lighting the Deepam could hurt the sentiments of another community, asking whether Hindus would ever accept restrictions on lighting lamps inside their own homes, wearing clothes, or women wearing sarees on similar grounds. “I will expire someday in the future anyway, so I don’t mind expiring fighting for the Murugan Deepam,” the devotee said. Local auto-rickshaw drivers have also reportedly come forward in support of lighting the lamp atop the hill as directed by the court.
Hindu Munnani Demonstration and Security Measures
On November 18, police tightened security arrangements around Thiruparankundram hill ahead of a protest organized by the Hindu Munnani demanding that the Karthigai Deepam be lit atop the hilltop pillar.
Support Us
Satyagraha was born from the heart of our land, with an undying aim to unveil the true essence of Bharat. It seeks to illuminate the hidden tales of our valiant freedom fighters and the rich chronicles that haven't yet sung their complete melody in the mainstream.
While platforms like NDTV and 'The Wire' effortlessly garner funds under the banner of safeguarding democracy, we at Satyagraha walk a different path. Our strength and resonance come from you. In this journey to weave a stronger Bharat, every little contribution amplifies our voice. Let's come together, contribute as you can, and champion the true spirit of our nation.
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
| ICICI Bank of Satyaagrah | Razorpay Bank of Satyaagrah | PayPal Bank of Satyaagrah - For International Payments |
If all above doesn't work, then try the LINK below:
Please share the article on other platforms
DISCLAIMER: The author is solely responsible for the views expressed in this article. The author carries the responsibility for citing and/or licensing of images utilized within the text. The website also frequently uses non-commercial images for representational purposes only in line with the article. We are not responsible for the authenticity of such images. If some images have a copyright issue, we request the person/entity to contact us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and we will take the necessary actions to resolve the issue.
Related Articles
- MLAs, bureaucrats purchasing land around Ram Mandir site through relatives after the Ayodhya verdict: Yogi Adityanath orders inquiry
- In the wake of the Madras HC's order banning non-Hindus from temple entry, Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams' announcement to explore Muslims participation in Srivari Seva challenges traditional boundaries, igniting a complex debate on inclusivity & sanctity
- "भोजशाला तो बस झांकी है, अब काशी-मथुरा बाकी है": Ending a centuries-old dispute, the Madhya Pradesh High Court definitively declared Dhar's Bhojshala complex a historical Saraswati temple founded by Raja Bhoj, restoring Hindu worship rights forever
- Madras High Court ends decades-old dispute by cancelling illegal sale of 3.93 acres of Arulmigu Annamalainathar Temple land in Kadayanallur, orders restoration to the deity and rejects revival of the void auction
- Disputed Gyanvapi case: Muslim side urges court not to make the details of the findings in the mosque’s video survey public, Hindu and Muslim parties are at loggerheads over whether there is a Shivling or a fountain
- Taking a dig at Samajwadi Party, Yogi stated that no one will know Uttar Pradesh by ‘Saifai Mahotsav’ and the people who organised it are now ‘past’: UP is now known for Kumbh and Ayodhya Deepotsav
- Madhya Pradesh HC accepted petition for stay on Muslims performing Namaz in the compound of Bhojshala monument: Read how an educational centre and a historic temple of Goddess Saraswati became Kamal Maulana mosque
- "Ayodhya hui hamari, ab Kashi-Mathura ki baari": Plea submitted in Mathura Court to secure Shahi Idgah Masjid to protect Hindu sacred artefacts after Shivling discovered at wuzukhana in Gyanvapi premises
- The Indian Finance Ministry officially denies viral rumors claiming the government plans to seize sacred temple gold to issue monetization bonds or create strategic reserves, urging citizens' caution
- "The greatness of a culture can be found in its festivals": India is a land of festivals, sometimes rather very unique like Chamayavilakku festival which is celebrated in Kerala and is unique because here men dress up as women to worship Devi Bhagavathy
- "History stolen, heritage lost": Kundavai Jainalayam Temple of the Chola dynasty, suffers a profound loss with its ancient idol's theft, ex-IPS Pon Manickavel dives deep, revealing a maze of negligence, smuggling, and India's unguarded cultural heritage
- HRCE flexes muscles to arrest a YouTuber Karthik Gopinath for collecting funds to restore murtis vandalized in an HRCE controlled temple, had moved funds to Padma Shri famed sculptor VK Munusamy to build the broken statues
- In a significant discovery Hindu temple structure with ornate columns found inside a mosque in Mangaluru, locals suspect the presence of a temple in the past: VHP leaders asked to stop work till documents verified
- In Bareilly, Akram, Shahrukh, and Arshad arrested for temple vandalism, while 35 others were detained following Hindu-Muslim clashes during Muharram, prompting bulldozer action against illegal property expansions amid severe communal tensions
- "हर हर गंगे": 250-year-old Ganga Maharani Temple in Bareilly, illegally occupied for 40 years by Wajid Ali, reclaimed after DM’s probe; Hindu groups celebrated by removing Islamic flags, hoisting saffron, and planning purification with Sundarkand Path

























