Skip to main content

|   Subscribe   |   donation   Support Us    |   donation

Log in
Register


"खिसियानी बिल्ली खंभा नोचे ": Rahul Gandhi ignited intense backlash at the Hyderabad Bharat Summit by claiming India is no longer a democracy then laughing as an imported Italian socialist demanded the elected government resign over election claims

A year prior, the Election Commission had already addressed the very slogan Gandhi was now attempting to export.
 |  Satyaagrah  |  Politics
India is No Longer a Democracy: Rahul Gandhi’s Imported Applause, an Italian Slogan, and a Lecture 1.4 Billion People Did Not Ask For
India is No Longer a Democracy: Rahul Gandhi’s Imported Applause, an Italian Slogan, and a Lecture 1.4 Billion People Did Not Ask For

On Saturday in Hyderabad, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha told a room full of invited foreigners that the nation—the very same nation that empowers him to hold his esteemed office—is “actually no longer a democracy.” Following this bold declaration, he laughed as an Italian socialist translated a Congress campaign slogan into English, essentially demanding that India’s elected government step down from power.

If this is truly what a deceased democracy looks like, it certainly knows how to host a remarkably well-attended valedictory session.

The assertion that the death of Indian democracy was “proven” was not supported by evidence; it was simply repeated as if repetition alone could make it a fact.

Rahul Gandhi’s choice of words was far from careless. It was his central thesis. “It is important for the democratic movement on the planet that India remains a democracy,” he proclaimed during the valedictory session of the Bharat Summit on November 14, an event hosted by the Congress-led Telangana government. “What we have found and proven is that India is actually no longer a democracy.”

The word “proven” carries significant weight. It intrinsically demands tangible proof. Yet, what the audience received was merely the same old allegation, newly repackaged for an international crowd. He claimed that the Opposition had been “in shock, not for a year, not for two years, but for an entire decade.”

Turning his focus to Maharashtra, he alleged a stark discrepancy between the Lok Sabha and Assembly elections, claiming the Opposition secured almost the same number of votes but ended up with drastically different results. He further asserted that the roughly seven million new voters added to the electoral rolls in the three months prior to the Assembly election had “all” voted for the BJP. Questioning the integrity of the process, he asked, “How can the election be legitimate if the Election Commission declares 140 million voters to be illegal?” However, he failed to explain where this staggering figure came from or how he could possibly know the voting choices of every single newly added elector.

These statements are allegations, and they remain just that—allegations without evidence.

The comparison regarding Maharashtra simply does not hold up when one examines the actual vote shares. The Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) did secure 30 of the state’s 48 Lok Sabha seats in 2024, only to win a mere 49 out of 288 Assembly seats a few months later. If you only look at the number of seats won, the shift might appear mysterious. But when you count the actual votes, the mystery dissolves. Data from the Hindustan Times reveals that the two main alliances were nearly tied in the Lok Sabha elections, with 43.9 per cent against 43.5 per cent. Fast forward to the Assembly elections, and the Mahayuti alliance saw its vote share surge to 51.3 per cent, while the MVA’s share plummeted to 35.4 per cent. These were not the same votes resulting in a different outcome; rather, it was a clearly documented shift in the electorate's preference (Hindustan Times Election Data).

A year prior, the Election Commission had already addressed the very slogan Gandhi was now attempting to export. On August 17, 2025, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar firmly stated that using terms like “vote chori” (vote theft) was an “insult to the Constitution.” He clarified that the Commission could not act on such grave accusations without a sworn oath and noted the conspicuous absence of any proof. He offered a blunt ultimatum: “Give an oath, or apologise to the nation. There is no third option. If we don’t get an affidavit within seven days, this would mean that all these allegations are baseless.” It was later reported that the deadline passed without any affidavit being submitted, leading an official to state that the claims were effectively “invalidated.”

Yet, the slogan did not fade away. Instead, it travelled all the way to Hyderabad and even acquired an Italian translation.

The Italian speaker was not just a random guest who strayed off course; he was the embodiment of the message itself.

Giacomo Filibeck, the secretary-general of the Party of European Socialists, did not accidentally stumble upon a Congress talking point. He intentionally recited it. After praising Gandhi’s campaign for “one person, one vote,” he delivered the punchline the audience had been waiting for: “Vote Chor Gaddi Chhod.” He even provided his own translation: “Vote thief, leave your seat.”

He then took it a step further, declaring, “Democracy is under attack in India, and we need to defend it. And the best way to defend it is to stand by Rahul Gandhi and the Indian Congress Party.”

This was not a minor comment on the technicalities of electoral rolls. This was a European political official standing on Indian soil, instructing Indian citizens that the defense of their own democracy must run exclusively through one specific political party and the heir of one specific family. Throughout this display, Gandhi was visibly laughing and applauding.

Union Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju posed the most pertinent question: “Have you ever seen anyone laughing when India is insulted by a foreigner? I’m not asking about which Indian goes abroad to insult India.” Home Minister Amit Shah also weighed in, stating that the Congress had “invited propagators of leftist ideology from across the country and abroad,” and accused Gandhi of having “worked to defame India across the entire world by expressing anti-India views at an international conference.”

This was not Filibeck’s first time playing the role of a foreign supporter for another nation's opposition. Back in April 2018, the Philippines denied him entry at the Mactan-Cebu airport and promptly deported him the very same day. He had arrived there at the invitation of the opposition party, Akbayan (Reuters on Filibeck Deportation).

Congress MP Pramod Tiwari attempted to defend the situation by arguing that “if a foreigner comes and says this, there is a need for introspection.” However, relying on a foreign official to echo a domestic slogan is not introspection. It is simply outsourcing an argument that the party failed to win at the ballot box.

Furthermore, a cancelled visa does not equate to the collapse of a republic.

Another piece of evidence in Gandhi’s indictment of Indian democracy was an apology. “I would like to apologise to the many delegates and leaders who were scheduled to attend but were not allowed to come by the Government of India,” he said. “It is not our fault, but it gives you a sense of what we are dealing with in our country.”

Adding to this narrative, Congress MP Shashi Tharoor alleged that 115 out of the 315 speakers who were supposedly “cleared” by the Ministry of External Affairs were ultimately refused entry or had their visas cancelled. He claimed this was done “apparently on the instructions of the Union Ministry of Home Affairs.” Tharoor lamented the situation, calling it a shame that “a proud democracy has become so insecure that it must stifle any voices it fears will be critical.”

It must be noted that the figure of 115 is solely Tharoor’s allegation. The Indian government has not confirmed this number. When questioned about the controversy during a Ministry of External Affairs briefing on November 13, spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal offered a straightforward response: “Visa matters are sovereign functions of any country or any government.”

His statement was entirely accurate. Every sovereign nation has the fundamental right to decide who is permitted to cross its borders. A denied visa is not proof that “India is actually no longer a democracy.”

Interestingly, even Italy has now effectively told its socialist representative to back down.

The most compelling rebuttal to Filibeck’s comments came from his own country. On November 16, Deborah Bergamini, a leader within Forza Italia and a coalition ally of Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, addressed the situation. “I believe that, in a democracy, everyone is free to put forward whatever arguments or accusations they choose, provided, of course, that they can substantiate them,” she stated.

She went on to emphasize that it was “inappropriate to intervene in the domestic political debates of a major friendly nation.” She then delivered a line that should resonate with anyone who understands the scale of Indian elections: “Moreover, as Europeans, we find it inappropriate to lecture on democracy a nation that enables 970 million citizens to cast their votes. India possesses its own political institutions and judiciary; any disputes or grievances should be addressed in accordance with, and with respect for, the established rules of democracy.”

This is the mature, grown-up perspective. If there are genuine disputes regarding electoral rolls or election fairness, the appropriate course of action is to take those grievances to the Election Commission and the judiciary. The solution is not to import a European socialist to chant “leave your seat” in Hyderabad and then present that chant as a verified finding.

The Opposition’s attempts at whataboutism were incredibly weak. Congress spokesperson Girija Shetkar questioned whether the phrase “Abki baar Trump sarkar,” used by Prime Minister Narendra Modi during the 2019 'Howdy Modi' event in Houston, wasn't also a comment on another country’s internal affairs. Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut offered a rather bizarre comparison: “If Modi can offer Melody chocolates to the Italian Prime Minister, then an Italian politician can come here and speak about this country.” These are not valid analogies. Sharing a stage with a US president at a diaspora rally is fundamentally different from inviting a foreign party official to explicitly demand the resignation of India’s elected government. A box of toffees does not establish a doctrine of foreign political supervision.

The script being used is old; only the accent delivering it is new.

This narrative did not suddenly begin in Hyderabad. Over a year earlier, in February 2023, Gandhi told an audience at Cambridge University that “Indian democracy is under pressure and under attack.” During that speech, he also introduced the overarching theme he would repeat years later: that preserving Indian democracy was “more than just about India,” because it was fundamentally “about the democratic structure and democratic system on the planet.”

The rhetoric used in Hyderabad was essentially the same sermon, just delivered at a higher volume. In Cambridge, the claim was that democracy was “under attack.” By the time he reached Hyderabad, the claim had escalated to the assertion that India was “actually no longer a democracy,” complete with an Italian official on hand to nod in agreement. The Congress party has not spent the last three years meticulously assembling a legal case to present under oath. Instead, it seems to have spent that time searching for sympathetic rooms—preferably filled with foreign audiences—where their accusations can sound much larger and more profound than the actual evidence allows.

Amit Shah’s political counter-argument was blunt and difficult to dismiss. He stated that the Congress was simply “venting the frustration” that comes from losing three consecutive Lok Sabha elections. He advised Gandhi that if he truly desired power, he should “stop your foreign trips and start visiting the villages of India.” The reality remains that the BJP-led alliance emerged victorious in the 2014, 2019, and 2024 elections. Gandhi currently serves as the Leader of the Opposition precisely because those democratic elections took place, and because the very system he now pronounces dead still guarantees him a prominent platform from which to voice his dissent.

The ultimate test of these claims is straightforward: put them under oath, or stop peddling them to foreign audiences.

A democracy is not proven false simply because an opposition party suffers an electoral defeat, nor is it dismantled by a cancelled visa, or by a European socialist brought in to recite the losing side’s campaign slogan in a foreign accent. A democracy is truly tested by whether serious allegations of electoral theft are brought before the proper institutions—institutions specifically built to hear such cases—under oath, with concrete evidence, and in a timely manner.

Gandhi, however, opted for a different kind of test. He chose to tell a foreign audience that the death of Indian democracy had already been “proven.” He treated a standard government visa decision as a definitive character certificate for the entire republic, and he laughed as Filibeck demanded that the Government of India vacate its position. The moral high ground does not require hosting an international summit. If the Leader of the Opposition truly possesses proof that India is “actually no longer a democracy,” he is obligated to submit that proof in a sworn affidavit, just as the Election Commission formally requested him to do back in August 2025. If he has concrete evidence that seven million new voters in Maharashtra all inexplicably voted for the BJP, he should present that data, booth by booth, within the legal forums provided for exactly this purpose. If he is unable to do so, he should cease asking the international community to accept a political slogan as a final, verified verdict.

The alternative approach displayed in Hyderabad is far less appealing. It involves telling 970 million Indian voters that their participation in the democratic process is nothing but a fraud, importing a foreign official to lead chants demanding the elected government's resignation, and then framing the resulting applause as a heroic defense of democracy. This approach does not demonstrate political courage. Instead, it looks like a political campaign that has simply run out of domestic rooms where such sweeping claims can be made without being immediately challenged for proof.

Support Us


Satyagraha was born from the heart of our land, with an undying aim to unveil the true essence of Bharat. It seeks to illuminate the hidden tales of our valiant freedom fighters and the rich chronicles that haven't yet sung their complete melody in the mainstream.

While platforms like NDTV and 'The Wire' effortlessly garner funds under the banner of safeguarding democracy, we at Satyagraha walk a different path. Our strength and resonance come from you. In this journey to weave a stronger Bharat, every little contribution amplifies our voice. Let's come together, contribute as you can, and champion the true spirit of our nation.

Satyaagrah Razorpay PayPal
 ICICI Bank of SatyaagrahRazorpay Bank of SatyaagrahPayPal Bank of Satyaagrah - For International Payments

If all above doesn't work, then try the LINK below:

Pay Satyaagrah

Please share the article on other platforms

To Top

DISCLAIMER: The author is solely responsible for the views expressed in this article. The author carries the responsibility for citing and/or licensing of images utilized within the text. The website also frequently uses non-commercial images for representational purposes only in line with the article. We are not responsible for the authenticity of such images. If some images have a copyright issue, we request the person/entity to contact us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and we will take the necessary actions to resolve the issue.


Related Articles

Related Articles




JOIN SATYAAGRAH SOCIAL MEDIA